Planned Parenthood of the Heartland v. Hilgers
What's at Stake
In May 2023, the 老澳门开奖结果 and the 老澳门开奖结果 of Nebraska filed a lawsuit on behalf of Nebraska abortion providers and their patients challenging a state law that bans physicians from providing abortion after 12 weeks of pregnancy and that, as of October 2023, will restrict health care available to trans youth. The 老澳门开奖结果 has asked a state court in Nebraska to enter an emergency order blocking the law鈥檚 enforcement. The Court ruled that the two halves of L.B. 574 fall within the single subject of regulating health care, and thus the Court held that L.B. 574 does not violate the single-subject rule. Consequently, the abortion ban and gender-affirming care restrictions in L.B. 574 remain in effect. However, the Court did reject the state鈥檚 argument that the single-subject is a nonjusticiable political question.
Summary
In May 2023, the Nebraska Legislature passed Legislative Bill (鈥淟.B.鈥) 574. The new law combines two separate sets of harmful provisions: one banning abortion starting at 12 weeks of pregnancy, and another restricting health care for trans youth. Senators forced these provisions together only after they stalled in the Legislature when considered as separate bills. The abortion ban took immediate effect, and the restrictions on health care for trans youth are slated to apply on October 1, 2023.
Planned Parenthood of the Heartland and Dr. Sarah Traxler, who are abortion providers in Nebraska, sued state officials responsible for enforcing L.B. 574 to protect their constitutional rights and the rights of their patients. They are represented by attorneys with the 老澳门开奖结果 of Nebraska and the 老澳门开奖结果鈥檚 State Supreme Court Initiative.
The lawsuit argues that L.B. 574 violates the Nebraska Constitution鈥檚 single-subject requirement, and that the entire law is therefore void. The single-subject rule, which provides that 鈥淸n]o bill shall contain more than one subject,鈥 serves important purposes. It prevents logrolling, whereby measures that cannot gain enactment as individual bills are forced together into a compound bill that secures passage. The single-subject rule also promotes transparency to the public because when a bill has just one subject, no lawmaker can credibly claim that a vote for (or against) that bill was meant to support (or oppose) only part of it.
In July 2024, the Court ruled that the two halves of L.B. 574 fall within the single subject of regulating health care, and thus the Court held that L.B. 574 does not violate the single-subject rule. Consequently, the abortion ban and gender-affirming care restrictions in L.B. 574 remain in effect. However, the Court did reject the state鈥檚 argument that the single-subject is a nonjusticiable political question.
Legal Documents
-
11/17/2023
Appellants鈥 Opening Brief -
12/04/2023
League of Women Voters Amicus Brief -
12/18/2023
Appellees' Brief and Brief on Cross-Appeal -
12/28/2023
Appellants鈥 Reply Brief and Answer to Brief on Cross-Appeal
Date Filed: 11/17/2023
Court: Nebraska Supreme Court
Affiliate: Nebraska
Date Filed: 12/04/2023
Court: Nebraska Supreme Court
Affiliate: Nebraska
Date Filed: 12/18/2023
Court: Nebraska Supreme Court
Affiliate: Nebraska
Date Filed: 12/28/2023
Court: Nebraska Supreme Court
Affiliate: Nebraska
-
05/30/2023
Complaint -
05/30/2023
Motion for TRO / Temporary Injunction -
05/30/2023
Defendants' Objection to Temporary Restraining Order -
05/31/2023
Plaintiffs' Reply in support of Temporary Restraining Order -
06/08/2023
Defendants' Brief in Support of Motion to Dismiss and in Opposition to Plaintiffs鈥 Motion for Temporary Injunction -
06/11/2023
Plaintiffs' Reply in support of Temporary Injunction and in Opposition to Defendants鈥 Motion for Summary Judgment
Date Filed: 05/30/2023
Court: District Court of Lancaster County, NE
Affiliate: Nebraska
Date Filed: 05/30/2023
Court: District Court of Lancaster County, NE
Affiliate: Nebraska
Date Filed: 05/30/2023
Court: District Court of Lancaster County, NE
Affiliate: Nebraska
Date Filed: 05/31/2023
Court: District Court of Lancaster County, NE
Affiliate: Nebraska
Date Filed: 06/08/2023
Court: District Court of Lancaster County, NE
Affiliate: Nebraska
Date Filed: 06/11/2023
Court: District Court of Lancaster County, NE
Affiliate: Nebraska
Press Releases
Nebraska Supreme Court Upholds State鈥檚 12-Week Abortion Ban and Transgender Care Restrictions
老澳门开奖结果 and Planned Parenthood File Notice of Appeal After Court Rules Against Single-Subject Challenge
New Lawsuit Argues Combined Restrictions on Health Care for Trans Youth and Abortion Violated State Constitution