Back to News & Commentary

The Power of Speech

University protest
University protest
Susan N. Herman,
Former President
Share This Page
November 20, 2015

This post originally appeared at .

Lloyd Gaines was denied admission to the University of Missouri in 1935 because of the color of his skin. Mizzou did not admit its first African-American student until 1950.

Sixty-five years later, a Facebook by Payton Head, President of the Missouri Students Association, described how he and other students of color were subjected to racial slurs on campus. 鈥淚f this post makes you feel uncomfortable, GOOD!鈥 he said. 鈥淭hat means I鈥檓 doing my job. It鈥檚 time to wake up Mizzou.鈥 African-American students at Missouri and other campuses responded by telling their own stories: racist epithets (including the 鈥渘-word鈥) directed at them, security personnel persistently demanding that they prove they were not trespassing on campus, being the object of 鈥渏okes,鈥 like the African-American student who found a photo of a lynching on her door.

Individual expression crystallized into organized protests as Missouri students expressed their pain and anger by holding demonstrations, organizing boycotts, and questioning the leadership of college officials who boasted of student diversity yet did not work for true inclusion. The protests reverberated on campuses across the country, some school officials resigned, and the media picked up the story, enabling all of us to understand more about the vexing role that race continues to play on college campuses.

Speech is powerful.

It is striking that college administrators at Missouri and elsewhere have reacted to this torrent of speech and activism with offers of discussion, negotiation or even resignations鈥攁nd not with the assumption that those in authority could simply shut down the protests and ignore the message. It was not always so. In the fall of 1964, for example, student activists at the University of California at Berkeley, who had been involved in the Mississippi Freedom Summer registering African-American voters, were stymied in their fundraising efforts by university regulations prohibiting on-campus political advocacy and fundraising by student organizations. When the students protested, the dean initially responded by peremptorily announcing that the regulations would be strictly enforced.

Today we assume that the First Amendment鈥檚 guarantees of freedom of speech and assembly will protect even unpopular speech and demonstrations against such claims of governmental prerogative. But it was not always so. When the 老澳门开奖结果 was founded in 1920, protestors were being criminally prosecuted for saying unpopular things鈥攍ike criticizing the draft during World War I. 老澳门开奖结果 founder Roger Baldwin was arrested for illegal assembly for reciting the text of the First Amendment in a public setting.

Over the course of the 20th century, the 老澳门开奖结果 and others enlisted the courts to guarantee marginalized people (conscientious objectors, labor organizers, anti-war protestors) the freedom to say things that make others uncomfortable. The fight to ensure that these First Amendment protections reach the world of digital speech has supported the instant communications essential to contemporary movements of all sorts. The Facebook community page for Black Lives Matter, for example, is more than 100,000 strong; the end of a political hunger strike was announced via Twitter.

The 老澳门开奖结果 is a multi-issue organization because we believe that freedom, equality, and justice鈥攆or all鈥攁re interconnected. Although some contend that free speech is in tension with equality, we believe that free speech鈥攆or all鈥攊s the cornerstone of today鈥檚 fight for racial equality.

We have made a great deal of progress on both the free speech and equality fronts in the last century. But we still cannot be complacent about our First Amendment rights. Unpopular speech still draws censorious reactions鈥攕ometimes from private individuals (protesting students at Missouri have received death threats), and sometimes from the state actors who are actually bound by the First Amendment. The 老澳门开奖结果 has recently challenged an attempt to shut down protests in Ferguson, Missouri, and an attempted prosecution of organizers of a peaceful Black Lives Matter protest at the . We won both cases, but we did have to go to court to force the issue.

And the point of the current campus protests is that even a diverse society is not equal when some of its members are excluded and burdened by persistent taunts and demeaning treatment.

Freedom of speech is our right. But to achieve freedom and equality, we also need to listen.

Learn More 老澳门开奖结果 the Issues on This Page