Back to News & Commentary

Why Is Chelsea Manning Prohibited From Having Caitlyn Jenner鈥檚 Vanity Fair Issue & The Senate Torture Report?

Photo of Caitlyn Jenner's Vanity Fair cover, Malala, and a toothbrush
Photo of Caitlyn Jenner's Vanity Fair cover, Malala, and a toothbrush
Chase Strangio,
Co-Director,
老澳门开奖结果 LGBTQ & HIV Rights Project
Share This Page
August 17, 2015

For Chelsea Manning the last five years have been a fight to survive. She has faced the and endured the in Kuwait and again while awaiting trial at Quantico in Virginia. She has come out as a trans woman and fought for her voice and her health care. She still fights for both as she also continues her long legal fight for freedom.

Through it all she has continued to . Her voice has become central to our movements for government transparency and transgender justice.

But she is now facing another fight that threatens to silence her.

On July 9, military officials confiscated from the convicted WikiLeaker and trans advocate鈥檚 cell at Fort Leavenworth. The 鈥減rohibited鈥 items copies of Caitlyn Jenner鈥檚 Vanity Fair cover issue, the Senate Intelligence Committee鈥檚 鈥Torture Report,鈥 and an expired tube of toothpaste.

Chelsea Manning's confiscated items

At the time, Chelsea was not informed why these items were taken. Her cell was searched, and they were removed when she was placed in solitary confinement for 24 hours following an investigation into allegations that she was 鈥渄isrespectful鈥 to an officer.

For almost a month, Chelsea, an 老澳门开奖结果 client, awaited clarity about the charges and requested that her reading materials be returned to her. But the military denied those requests.

Now Chelsea will go before a disciplinary board on Tuesday, during which she will face charges for disrespecting an officer, misusing medication, and possessing prohibited items.

But the more that emerge about these charges, the more concerning this all becomes. The alleged encounter that prompted the 鈥渄isrespect鈥 charge involved Chelsea requesting a lawyer when she realized that she was being accused of wrongdoing. As for 鈥渕isusing medication,鈥 that charged is based solely on possessing toothpaste that expired in April of this year. And the 鈥減rohibited鈥 property she had in her possession included, among other things, issues of Vanity Fair, OUT magazine, the Advocate, and the Cosmopolitan issue that included her own interview.

If all that wasn鈥檛 bad enough, the possible punishment for these alleged infractions includes indefinite solitary confinement.

Since supporters learned of these charges and started a campaign to have them dropped, the military has responded with assurances that Chelsea鈥檚 treatment will be 鈥.鈥 But subsequent to that statement Chelsea was inexplicably to the law library as she prepares to go before the disciplinary board. Because she is not entitled to have counsel present at her board, this access is especially important.

Hopefully with public pressure and increasing scrutiny, the charges against Chelsea will be dismissed, and she will not be subjected to the torture of solitary or any other punishment that further restricts her access to public engagement and the support systems that she has cultivated from prison.

But regardless of the ultimate outcome, the fact that she has had to face this discipline at all is a concerning reflection of how our incarceration systems attempt to isolate and dehumanize those held behind prison walls.

Even though experts agree that solitary confinement is a , we continue to hear reports of people being sent to solitary for alleged infractions as absurd as having an expired tube of toothpaste or . For like Chelsea, solitary often becomes a default placement for 鈥渟afety鈥 reasons in an inherently unsafe system.

Incarceration is itself a form of isolation 鈥 a mechanism for cutting people off from their families and support systems and taking them out of the community. Within that isolation, the added disruption and harms that flow from solitary and other disciplinary mechanisms cannot be overstated. For Chelsea, her books, magazines, and reports are a part of her and they help build her voice. And this voice is her connection to a network of people who uplift her and are uplifted and inspired by her.

If Chelsea loses her reading materials permanently, or if she is sent to solitary, or if she is otherwise disciplined because she asked for a lawyer or had old toothpaste or wanted to read about Caitlyn Jenner or the Senate Torture Report, then we all lose. We lose a piece of her voice in our public discourse, and we lose another fight against a disruptive and dehumanizing system of so-called justice.

Learn More 老澳门开奖结果 the Issues on This Page