Back to News & Commentary

The Consequences and Costs of a 287(g) Jail Agreement: One Tennessee County鈥檚 Story

Immigrants Rights are Civil Rights
Immigrants Rights are Civil Rights
Lindsay Kee,
老澳门开奖结果 of Tennessee
Share This Page
January 2, 2013

Though street-level 287(g) agreements are ending, ICE is continuing the troubled 287(g) program in jails

鈥淚 had a girl who came to school鈥 ninth grader and she was very distraught, crying鈥,鈥 a local Nashville teacher said when asked about the impact of the 287(g) program, an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) program that delegates immigration enforcement authority to participating law enforcement agencies across the country.

鈥淪he had witnessed a shooting outside of her apartment complex鈥he police鈥nterviewed her. One of the guys who was involved saw her talking about it鈥o he had someone go and threaten her family later that night, and they have not told the police because they鈥檙e scared to鈥The family] didn鈥檛 feel safe. They never actually as a family went to the police and said, 鈥榃e were threatened鈥欌Instead] they moved.鈥

This incident is but one of many examples of the erosion of public trust in law enforcement, and the consequent deterioration of public safety, caused by 287(g) and documented in the 老澳门开奖结果 of Tennessee鈥檚 new report, 鈥.鈥

Other local advocates in the report had heard from clients or their family members who had been victims of robbery, domestic violence, vandalism and sexual exploitation who had never reported these crimes to the police for fear of immigration implications for themselves or a family member.

When a significant portion of the population feels uncomfortable reporting crimes they have witnessed or experienced, it poses a public-safety threat for all residents. This is especially ironic given the 287(g) program鈥檚 of responding to 鈥渋mmigration violators who pose a threat to national security or public safety.鈥

As our demonstrates, the damage to community-police relations incurred by the Davidson County 287(g) program stems from its encouragement of racial profiling and the deportation of nearly 10,000 people largely for minor, often traffic-related, offenses during its implementation.

An analysis of probable cause statements made by police officers upon arrest revealed some officers using language describing race, ethnicity or immigration status. This suggests that those officers mistakenly believed that these factors made people more eligible for arrest.

Indeed, after implementation of 287(g), arrests for the single charge of 鈥淣o Driver鈥檚 License鈥 that led to removal increased 136 percent. When 鈥淣o Driver鈥檚 License鈥濃攕omething that cannot be determined until after a stop is already made鈥攊s the sole charge, it suggests racial profiling. Driving without a license, a misdemeanor, topped the list of charges that became a gateway for deportation under Davidson County鈥檚 287(g) program.

While 287(g) was sold as an effective mechanism to deport dangerous criminals and make Nashville safer, when you look at arrests of foreign-born people while it was in place, the percentage of arrests for the most dangerous crimes actually decreased.

Instead, 287(g) has denigrated public safety by creating fear of law enforcement in the immigrant community, making people less likely to report crimes. Another local advocate illustrated the fear of law enforcement caused by 287(g) when describing a client.

鈥淎 mother shared that her daughter was married to an abusive husband and it was so bad that the family knew that it really wasn鈥檛 a healthy relationship...Even in the face of knowing that that was not a safe situation for their daughter, they didn鈥檛 know what to do because they didn鈥檛 want to call the police鈥hey were really afraid of鈥eporting the abuse that was happening from their daughter鈥檚 husband鈥hey were afraid that they would be deported.鈥

It is precisely this fear and the resultant weakening of community-police relations that has led law enforcement leaders across the country to speak out against 287(g), including the Police Executive Research Forum, the Police Foundation, and the Major Cities Chiefs Association.

Former Los Angeles Chief of Police William Bratton, who refused to participate in 287(g), perhaps summarized the negative impact of 287(g) best鈥攊n Davidson County and across the country鈥攚hen he said, 鈥淐riminals are the biggest beneficiaries when immigrants fear the police.鈥

on Davidson County, Tennessee鈥檚 287(g) program.

Learn more about immigration and customs enforcement: Sign up for breaking news alerts,, and .

Learn More 老澳门开奖结果 the Issues on This Page