Back to News & Commentary

Government Agencies Shouldn't Be Allowed to Destroy Their Paper Trail of Medical Abuse and Neglect

US Customs and Border Protection building facade.
Customs and Border Protection's request to destroy certain medical records will hinder oversight and obscure serious violations.
US Customs and Border Protection building facade.
Eunice Hyunhye Cho,
Senior Staff Attorney,
老澳门开奖结果 National Prison Project
Share This Page
January 12, 2024

Last year, , a medically vulnerable 8-year-old girl, died in Customs and Border Protection (CBP) detention after contract medical staff failed to review her medical records or consult with a physician and refused her emergency medical transport and care. As a court monitor concluded, Anadith鈥檚 death was a 鈥溾 pointing to an 鈥渦rgent need鈥 to improve 鈥淐BP medical oversight.鈥 Sadly, this kind of medical abuse and neglect is not an anomaly in CBP facilities. Last month, CBP employees , indicating that CBP鈥檚 contract oversight office has of serious violations in the provision of medical care at CBP detention facilities, including significant understaffing, and providing medical services without appropriate medical licenses.

In the midst of these disturbing developments, CBP has from the National Archives and Records Administration to destroy 鈥渕edical case files of persons in the custody of U.S. Customs and Border Protection鈥 after 20 years.

The medical records slated for destruction by CBP have long-term value for legal, research, historical, and accountability purposes. That鈥檚 why the 老澳门开奖结果 and 71 organizations, including the American Immigration Council and the Texas Civil Rights Project, as well as 165 academic scholars, filed a regulatory comment today to challenge CBP鈥檚 proposed destruction of these records.

The medical records in question are often the primary evidence of medical care (or lack thereof) received by people in CBP custody, and are key to government accountability efforts to address systemic medical neglect in CBP detention. These records are also critical to legal claims by individuals or their surviving family members 鈥 including people who may still have live legal challenges long after the incidents occurred, such as people with disabilities or those who were minors when the abuse or neglect occurred.

These medical records are also of significant historical importance: Historians have frequently turned to the National Archives for primary sources regarding the treatment of immigrants, including the use of as a basis for entry or exclusion, and access by migrants at the border. have also examined records from government agencies that provided medical care to immigrants, including the U.S. Public Health Service 鈥 a precursor to CBP鈥檚 current medical care providers.

Destruction of CBP鈥檚 medical records would eliminate an important primary source developed during CBP鈥檚 nascent period as an agency 鈥 from its establishment in 2003, to a time marked by policies of , and the use of , a purported public health measure to expel millions of immigrants during the COVID-19 pandemic.

CBP鈥檚 plans to destroy medical records will only serve to obscure its tragic record of medical neglect and inhibit efforts to hold the agency accountable. Each day, CBP holds approximately 15,000 migrants in short-term detention facilities while processing them at the border. CBP policy maintains that people should not be detained for longer than 72 hours in these facilities, often small, commonly referred to as hieleras (鈥渇reezers鈥 in Spanish). CBP, however, regularly detains people for as long as 10 days, and in many cases, for over 30 days. Government oversight agencies and advocates have detailed numerous incidents of negligent medical care to people in CBP custody, including denial of care to people with , a due to injury by a Border Patrol officer, and a .

An also highlighted multiple cases of medical neglect in CBP detention, including the denial of care to a pregnant person, which preceded a stillbirth; and withholding of prescription medication for a child detained after undergoing spinal surgery resulting from a car accident. At least in CBP custody in FY 2021 after having a medical emergency.

CBP鈥檚 treatment of migrants in its custody needs more transparency and documentation 鈥 not less. Like former challenges to the destruction of documents related to immigration detention, government agencies should not be allowed to destroy the paper trail of their incompetence and wrongdoing.

Learn More 老澳门开奖结果 the Issues on This Page