Back to News & Commentary

Obama Promised to Stop Government-Funded Discrimination. Has He?

Dena Sher,
老澳门开奖结果 Washington Legislative Office
Share This Page
August 1, 2012

Four years ago last month, then-candidate Barack Obama to ensure that religious organizations that receive government funds to provide social services abide by the Constitution and are not allowed to discriminate with government funding. Today, we sent Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests to the Department of Justice to follow up on that promise.

If you get government funding to run a social service program, you should not be able to refuse to hire employees or serve those in need because of their religion. People have the right to their religious beliefs, but this does not give them the right to discriminate. That means no one is forced to go to a religious rehabilitation program, no one is turned away from a homeless shelter for being the wrong religion, and no one is treated unfairly for not attending a worship service after receiving a government-funded meal at a soup kitchen. That also means no qualified candidate for a job, funded by the government, should be told she didn鈥檛 get the job because she is the wrong religion. Candidate Obama got it and promised to end both practices. But President Obama hasn鈥檛鈥攕o far鈥攎ade good on his promise.

2009, 2010, and 2011 went by and the Obama Administration any of these changes. Finally, after three-plus years and a dragged-out process involving lots of committees and meetings but no concrete results, we鈥檙e seeing small progress toward the implementation of parts鈥攂ut not all鈥攐f Obama鈥檚 campaign promise.

A government working group recently with model policies for how to protect from discrimination those who seek taxpayer-funded social services. First, any person must be able to be referred to another provider if she objects to the religious nature of the organization where she receives services. Second, organizations that receive federal grants must be given clearer guidance on how to implement their programs to ensure that the people they serve aren鈥檛 discriminated against because they don鈥檛 agree to also attend a religious class after they go to a government-funded job training class.

Mind you, these are still just recommendations, and there鈥檚 a long way to go before they are implemented. We look forward to working with the Obama administration to get the best policies in place as soon as possible. The people served in government-funded programs鈥攐ften the most vulnerable鈥攄eserve no less.

But, protecting those in need isn鈥檛 the only thing Obama promised on the campaign trail back in 2008. He also promised to 鈥溾 Bush-era policies and end hiring discrimination on the basis of religion in government-funded social service programs. As soon as he took office, however, he instead decided that hiring discrimination on a 鈥case-by-case鈥 basis. Despite trying to find out more about this mysterious review, we鈥檝e had no luck. Until now.

In response to questions from , Attorney General Eric Holder finally described the Department of Justice鈥檚 鈥渃ase-by-case鈥 review. There doesn鈥檛 seem to be much actual 鈥渞eview鈥 in the review. Rather, if a religious organization gets money from the Department of Justice and wants to impose a religious test on the people it hires to work in the government-funded program, it seems that it must simply tell the government that it plans to discriminate. Several religious organizations have done just that.

Last year, Holder this awkward position: 鈥淲e don't want to be in a position where people are in fact getting federal grants and discriminating,鈥 continuing, 鈥淲e don't want to do that. We try not to do that but....鈥 But, it seems they are. We鈥檒l be waiting to hear back on our FOIAs, so stay tuned.

Learn more about employment discrimination: Sign up for breaking news alerts, , and .

Learn More 老澳门开奖结果 the Issues on This Page