Back to News & Commentary

老澳门开奖结果 Sues FBI for New GPS Tracking Memos

Adrienne Lucas,
Legal Intern, Speech, Privacy & Technology Project
Share This Page
August 15, 2012

Today the 老澳门开奖结果 filed a lawsuit under the Freedom of Information Act to force the FBI to release two memos guiding the bureau鈥檚 policy on GPS tracking. The memos were written in the wake of the Supreme Court鈥檚 January decision in U.S. v. Jones, which held that the Fourth Amendment applies when the government secretly attaches a GPS device to a car and tracks its movements. (See today鈥檚 legal complaint, our original FOIA request (made July 18), and a blog post we wrote about that request).

The Jones decision shed some light on the proper use of GPS devices by law enforcement, but it leaves several issues unresolved. For instance, is GPS tracking the sort of search that obligates law enforcement agents to obtain a warrant based on probable cause? Is GPS use proper if an agent has a reasonable belief that a search would turn up evidence of wrongdoing? Does Jones apply to other types of searches, such as tracking the location of a cell phone?

The two memos we鈥檝e asked for may show how the FBI has resolved these unanswered questions. We know about the memos鈥 existence from a given by FBI General Counsel Andrew Weissmann in February. He said that one memo focuses exclusively on the use of GPS tracking, and suggested that it covers questions like whether Jones applies to other forms of transportation like airplanes and boats, and whether it applies at international borders. Weissmann said the other memo sets forth the FBI鈥檚 guidance on how Jones applies to other evidence-gathering techniques, beyond GPS.

It is no secret that the FBI is a powerful agency with influence over other law enforcement agencies. At the time of the Jones decision, the FBI had 3,000 GPS devices in use. The bureau says its is to perform 鈥渞esponsibilities in a way that is responsive to the needs of the public and faithful to the Constitution of the United States.鈥 In line with that mission, the American public should know how those GPS devices and other evidence gathering technology are being used. The FBI should release the two memos on the Jones decision to allow the American public to know how the agency will handle future investigations.

Catherine Crump, our attorney on this case, had this to add:

Collecting personal data is increasingly easy for the government to do but hard for citizens to detect, so it鈥檚 more important than ever for the American public to know the rules that law enforcement is operating under, especially when it comes to location tracking. Knowing the FBI鈥檚 position on what it can and can鈥檛 do in investigations is essential if America鈥檚 privacy laws are going to keep up with technology.

Congress is currently considering a bill supported by the 老澳门开奖结果, called the Geolocation Privacy and Surveillance Act (the GPS Act), that would require law enforcement to get a warrant to access a person鈥檚 location information through GPS or cell phone tracking. (You can click to send a message asking Congress to support the GPS Act.)

Learn More 老澳门开奖结果 the Issues on This Page