Back to News & Commentary

How to Decode the True Meaning of What NSA Officials Say

Jameel Jaffer,
Director, Knight First Amendment Institute
Brett Max Kaufman,
Senior Staff Attorney,
老澳门开奖结果 Center for Democracy
Share This Page
August 1, 2013

This piece was originally published on .

James Clapper, the director of national intelligence, about the scope of the National Security Agency's surveillance activities. The criticism is entirely justified. An equally insidious threat to the integrity of our national debate, however, comes not from officials' outright lies but from the language they use to tell the truth. When it comes to discussing government surveillance, U.S. intelligence officials have been using a vocabulary of misdirection鈥攁 language that allows them to say one thing while meaning quite another. The assignment of unconventional meanings to conventional words allows officials to imply that the NSA's activities are narrow and closely supervised, though neither of those things is true. What follows is a lexicon for decoding the true meaning of what NSA officials say.

Surveillance. Every time we pick up the phone, the NSA makes a note of whom we spoke to, when we spoke to him, and for how long鈥攁nd it's been doing this for seven years. After the call-tracking program was exposed, few people thought twice about attaching the label "surveillance" to it. Government officials, though, have , pointing out that this particular program doesn't involve the NSA actually listening to phone calls鈥攋ust keeping track of them. Their crabbed definition of "surveillance" allows them to claim that the NSA isn't engaged in surveillance even when it quite plainly is.

Read the rest of the NSA Lexicon on .

Learn more about government surveillance and other civil liberties issues: Sign up for breaking news alerts, , and .

Learn More 老澳门开奖结果 the Issues on This Page