Back to News & Commentary

Texas School District Refuses to Acknowledge First Amendment

Fleming Terrell,
老澳门开奖结果 of Texas
Share This Page
December 8, 2009

The Needville Independent School District (NISD) in Texas just isn鈥檛 willing to accept that a Houston-area kindergartener, identified in court by his initials A.A., wears his long braids as an exercise of his Native American religion鈥攏or that the U.S. Constitution and Texas鈥 Religious Freedom Restoration Act (TRFRA) require them to accommodate A.A鈥檚 religious exercise.

In November 2007, A.A.'s parents requested an exemption to the school district grooming code鈥檚 requirement that boys have short hair. After months of denying A.A.鈥檚 requests for this exemption, just days before the school year began in August 2008, NISD enacted a humiliating and uncomfortable policy that required A.A. to keep his hair in a single, tightly woven braid stuffed down the back of his shirt when at school. A.A. and his parents refused the school鈥檚 district鈥檚 mandate that he hide the braids that are a symbol of his faith, and A.A. spent a month segregated from his classmates in in-school suspension for standing up for his beliefs.

This punishment only stopped when the 老澳门开奖结果 and 老澳门开奖结果 of Texas filed a lawsuit in October 2008, and immediately after the filing, a temporary restraining order returned A.A. to class with his long braids. This past January, a (PDF) this policy violated A.A.'s First Amendment rights and violated the TRFRA.

But NISD鈥檚 struggle to force the boy to conform to their appearance standards without regard for his religious beliefs didn鈥檛 end there. , attorneys for NISD complained in oral argument before the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals that the district court improperly substituted its judgment for that of school administrators about how best to implement the school鈥檚 grooming code.

But the truth is that NISD unlawfully substituted its judgment for that of A.A. and his family about how best to practice their Native American faith. As the 老澳门开奖结果 argued in response, the Texas legislature, through TRFRA, requires NISD to look at the burden its punitive policy imposes on A.A. from the boy鈥檚 perspective, not their own. This echoes the deference federal courts have long given to individuals鈥 sincere interpretations of their religious beliefs鈥攁nd how they should be practiced鈥攗nder the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. Both clearly support the order returning A.A. to class, but since we found ourselves once again arguing the point in court last week, it seems that NISD still just doesn鈥檛 get it.

Learn More 老澳门开奖结果 the Issues on This Page