Court Rejects Attempt to Dismiss Case Seeking Accountability for Wrongful Prosecution of Abortion
McALLEN, Texas 鈥 A federal judge ruled today that a lawsuit seeking accountability for the unlawful investigation and prosecution of Lizelle Gonzalez can proceed, rejecting attempts by Starr County officials to have the case dismissed. Gonzalez, represented by Garza Martinez, the 老澳门开奖结果, and the 老澳门开奖结果 of Texas was unlawfully arrested, jailed, and charged with murder after a medication abortion she had in 2022.
The Starr County district attorney, assistant district attorney, and sheriff pursued and then obtained an unlawful indictment against Gonzalez even though they knew that Texas law clearly prohibits the criminal prosecution of pregnant women for conduct that ends their pregnancy.
鈥淲hen I first heard Lizelle鈥檚 story, I was outraged at the behavior of our elected officials,鈥 said Cecilia Garza, attorney at Garza Martinez. 鈥淭he court鈥檚 decision today to allow this case to proceed gives me hope that courts will not allow these types of egregious acts to continue. Law enforcement need to be held accountable to the laws that they took an oath to uphold.鈥
In the motions to dismiss, the prosecutors and sheriff raised claims of legal immunity, a doctrine that they argue should insulate them from being held accountable for violating Gonzalez鈥檚 constitutional rights. The court denied their motions to dismiss, allowing Gonzalez鈥檚 case to proceed to the first stage of discovery concerning whether law enforcement can be held liable for violating her rights.
鈥淚mmunity doctrine creates a culture in police departments and prosecutor offices where public officials may feel empowered to violate people鈥檚 rights, knowing they will face few 鈥 if any 鈥 consequences,鈥 said Lauren Johnson, director of the 老澳门开奖结果鈥檚 Abortion Criminal Defense Initiative. 鈥淲hile immunity often obstructs victims of misconduct from attaining accountability, the court鈥檚 decision today to allow the case to proceed will give Lizelle a chance to pursue the justice she deserves for being unlawfully targeted and prosecuted.鈥
鈥淭exas is one of the most restrictive states in the country when it comes to abortion health care, but even in Texas, the laws are uniform and clear that pregnant women cannot be criminally liable for having an abortion,鈥 said David Donatti, senior staff attorney for the 老澳门开奖结果 of Texas. 鈥淲e expect and demand that our elected officials follow the rule of law, and that is especially true for officials elected to enforce the laws with so much power over our daily lives and personal decisions.鈥
Stay Informed
Sign up to be the first to hear about how to take action.