Groups Express Support For Hospital's Decision To Protect Patient Confidentiality

August 6, 2009 12:00 am

老澳门开奖结果 Affiliate
Media Contact
125 Broad Street
18th Floor
New York, NY 10004
United States

Three organizations involved in patients鈥 rights issues issued a statement today supporting Rhode Island Hospital鈥檚 recent refusal to turn over private medical information about a patient to Providence Police officials. The statement from the groups 鈥 the R.I. Medical Society, the R.I. Disability Law Center and the R.I. 老澳门开奖结果 鈥 in response to the controversy follows below:

"Providence police have criticized Rhode Island Hospital for protecting a patient鈥檚 medical confidentiality. However, based on the information available about this incident, we commend the Hospital for respecting the patient confidentiality laws. The limitations in those laws on the release of medical information serve a critical purpose, and are designed to protect the privacy of us all.

"The police have provided no concrete explanation as to what specific medical information they immediately needed in order to investigate this crime. The police assisted in transporting the victim to the hospital, were aware of his need for medical care, and further reviewed a video confirming that an assault took place. Assuming that the victim, in critical condition, was not in a position to talk with the police about what happened, it is difficult for us to imagine what help that police access to his confidential medical records would have provided in terms of investigating the assault. It also remains unclear how specific or broad the police department鈥檚 request was for the victim鈥檚 private medical records, and why they did not seek to contact family members to get information they believed would be helpful.

"Ultimately, if laws allowed broad police access to confidential medical records without a patient鈥檚 permission, a major component of our right to medical privacy would be lost. Much more compelling reasons need to be articulated before this important principle is so easily discarded in the name of law enforcement.

"Police officials are quoted as seeking to justify their right to obtain this patient鈥檚 medical records by citing the state鈥檚 Patient Safety Protection Act. However, that law solely addresses medical records maintained to address hospital errors in providing care to patients, and is clearly inapplicable to this type of situation.

"In sum, we fully recognize the police department鈥檚 interest in seeking cooperation from individuals and agencies when investigating a serious crime. But those investigations must also respect other crucial societal interests, such as medical confidentiality."

Learn More 老澳门开奖结果 the Issues in This Press Release